95 Points -
Owen Bargreen, USA
94 Points -
Tim Atkin MW South Africa 2023 Report
93+ Points -
Anthony Mueller, Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
92 Points -
Wine Enthusiast, Jesica Vargas
95 Owen Bargreen, USA, December 2024
The brilliant 2022 Hamilton Russell Pinot Noir is a highly nuanced, stunning rendition of this wine winemaker Emul Ross. Sourced from their estate vineyards in Hemel-En-Aarde, this offers kumquat zest and black truffle crudo on the nose alongside shades of pomegranate seed and damp earth. The palate is laden with minerality, showing a smooth mouthfeel and glorious sense of length. Enjoy this stunner now and over the next fifteen years.
94 Tim Atkin MW South Africa 2023 Report
Rarely a Pinot Noir that one should be in a hurry to drink, the 2022 Hamilton Russell bottling needs time to develop and work its magic. This 2022 is comparatively serious and shuttered at the moment, with dark-fruited complexity, some clove spice from 10% whole clusters, grippy, sinewy tannins and stylish 36% new wood.
Jonathan Ray, The Spectator, March 2023
The 2022 Hamilton Russell Vineyards Pinot Noir is yet another sublime example of what this estate can do with the so-called Heartbreak Grape. I honestly believe there’s no better Pinot in all South Africa. It’s tight, elegant and reserved with soft, seductive red fruit and just a touch of something spicy on the finish. I love it.
James Viner, Lifestyle UK, August 2023
Made from low-yielding vines, this is a superb South African answer to red burgundy. Savoury, earthy, subtly spicy, pure and delicious, this classy Pinot has bolshy length and will cellar beautifully – but my goodness it is fascinating to drink now. A gorgeous rendition.
93+ Robert Parker's Wine Advocate, Anthony Mueller, February 2024
Popping out of the glass with succulent dark red cherries and fresh potpourri essence, the 2022 Pinot Noir bursts with notes of wild herbs and turned earth. Medium-bodied, the palate offers flavors of black raspberry with a firm-gripping tannic edge. It shows seductive florals with spicy flavors and ends with a food-friendly finish. Just under 20,000 bottles were filled after 10 months of barrel aging in 36% new French oak.
92 Wine Enthusiast, Jesica Vargas, April 2024
The Hamilton Russell winery is a pioneer in the Hemel-en-Aarde Valley and offers an elegant and spicy Pinot Noir. The nose opens with white pepper and nutmeg. An energised palate and tight tannins provide a good frame for strawberries, cherries and subtle dried herbs. Hints of cardamom appear in the aftertaste.
Sara d'Amato, Wine Align, Canada, December 2024
Albeit a splurge, this juicy-tart pinot exhibits just enough restraint to keep it from bursting forth with botanicals, dried herbs, ripe red cherries and spice. Structured like a Pommard but with the ethereal brightness and salinity of Hemel-en-Aarde.